Two companies that matter for AI search reported quarterly results within a day of each other, and both stocks fell. Alphabet reported on 28 October and Reddit on 29 October. The number that matters for GEO is not in either headline: Reddit said it will move towards a logged-in-only experience, at the same time its content deal with Google is up for renewal.
That raises a fair question. Is this a negotiating move, or is Reddit closing the door for good, with no crawlers and so no Reddit input for LLMs? The honest answer is that the public facts do not settle it. Here is what is known, what is not, and what to do in the meantime.
What the stock charts show
Both stocks fell after their results, but for different reasons.


Google Finance, one-month view, close of 3 November 2026. The one-month percentages in the screenshots include the weeks before the results, so they overstate the earnings reaction.
| Close 29 Oct | Close 3 Nov | |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit (RDDT) | $129.60 | $96.15 |
| Alphabet (GOOGL) | $283.82 | $280.03 |
The 29 October close for Reddit is from before the market reacted, because Reddit reported after that day’s trading. The Alphabet close already contains the reaction, a fall of 12.6% on that day, according to 24/7 Wall St..
Two different stories
Alphabet reported revenue of $127.6 billion, slightly under the $128.2 billion analysts expected, and adjusted earnings per share of $2.67 against $3.02 expected. Free cash flow was negative $9.07 billion, and the company said it expects capex to increase significantly in 2027, according to CNBC. Search revenue still grew 12% to $63.35 billion, below the $64.96 billion analysts expected. The market reacted to profit, cash flow and spending. It is not a verdict on search.
Reddit grew revenue 53% to $895 million, but the story was traffic. Search referrals fell by more than one million a week on average in October, which CEO Steve Huffman blamed on Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode. US daily active uniques fell 2%, the first US decline since the IPO, and Huffman warned that total users could fall by a low double-digit percentage in Q4. Guidance for Q4 adjusted EBITDA of $480 to $510 million came in below the $512 million analysts expected (figures as reported by 24/7 Wall St.).
The two stories are connected by one fact: Google’s AI answers send fewer people to the sites they draw from. They are not connected by the stock move. Alphabet did not fall because of Reddit, and Reddit did not fall because of Alphabet.
The login wall and the Google deal
Reddit said it will fully test a logged-in-only experience in select markets outside the US in Q4. Huffman said: “This is a test, but we are going to make this transition.” Asked whether a login wall makes Reddit harder to scrape, he answered “For sure.” Reddit has not said which markets, when a wider launch could follow, or how much revenue comes from logged-out visitors.
At the same time, the licensing deal with Google is open. The Wall Street Journal reported in July that Reddit had discussed shutting off Google’s access to its content for AI use. The deal, struck in 2024, is worth about $60 million a year and is reportedly ending soon, with talks about renewal (CNBC). A Reddit spokesperson said the company is approaching the negotiations “just like any business should, by focusing on doing what’s best for Reddit.”
Leverage or a permanent closure?
There are reasons to read it as leverage:
- The timing. A login wall announced while the largest licensing deal is up for renewal strengthens Reddit’s position: what is behind a wall can be sold.
- Huffman said Google “is crawling us as hard as ever” and that Reddit is “in active discussions” on licensing. The wall is aimed at unauthorised access, and licensed partners have contractual access.
- A wall protects the value of existing deals and the lawsuits against companies Reddit says scrape without paying.
There are also reasons to read it as permanent:
- Huffman’s “we are going to make this transition” is not language for a bargaining chip.
- Old Reddit already requires a login, a change made this summer.
- The business reason is lasting: if Google’s AI answers keep reducing referrals, logged-out traffic is worth less to Reddit every quarter, and logged-in users are where most of the monetisation sits.
Our reading is that these are not alternatives. A login wall is a policy and a lever at the same time, and Reddit does not need to choose which one it is to benefit from both. Treat anything beyond that as speculation, including ours: no one outside the negotiating rooms can tell what the renewal will look like.
What is still true today
- Reddit is not logged-in only. The test is limited to select markets outside the US, and the main reddit.com site is still browsable without an account.
- Reddit threads still appear in LLM answers, and the companies with licensing deals (Google and OpenAI) have their own access. If a wall does expand, the engines without a deal are the most likely to see less Reddit material.
- Nothing is irreversible. A login requirement is a policy. A test in a few markets can be widened, narrowed or dropped, and a deal that changes terms can open access again.
Why Reddit stays a channel for B2B
Whatever happens to crawlers, buyers are on the platform. In a SurveyMonkey and Reddit survey of 1,202 US business decision-makers, 23% had used Reddit for research, and 32% of software buyers. Reddit co-sponsored the research, so read the numbers as directional. They still say something simple: a part of your buyers read Reddit threads before they ever talk to you, and that does not depend on whether an LLM can see the thread.
What to do now
- Keep contributing where your buyers ask. Useful, honest answers in the relevant subreddits work for the humans who read them, and that value does not disappear if a crawler does.
- Do not measure Reddit only through LLM citations. Look at the threads that rank for your category, and ask new leads where they read about you.
- Freeze a baseline now. Run the same prompts every month and record how often Reddit is cited as a source in your category. If a wall reduces Reddit’s share, you will see it in the data and not in a headline.
- Make sure your own answers are citable elsewhere. Your own site, review platforms and documentation are sources you control, whichever way the Reddit decision goes.
Frequently asked questions
Is Reddit logged-in only now? No. Reddit will test it in select markets outside the US in Q4. Logged-out visitors can still browse the main site; only Old Reddit requires a login.
Is the login wall a negotiating tactic in the Google renewal? Nobody outside Reddit and Google knows. Both readings are supported by the public facts, and they can be true at the same time.
Should B2B brands stop investing in Reddit? No. A real share of B2B buyers uses it for research today, whatever happens to LLM access later.
